Using photos and videos as evidence

When it comes to deposit disputes, evidence is everything. A detailed inventory supported by clear photographs and video footage can make it much easier to demonstrate the condition of a property at the start and at the end of a tenancy. Without it, establishing what has changed during the tenancy can be difficult for all parties involved. 

Photographs and videos help create an objective record of the property, providing visual evidence that can support the written descriptions contained within an inventory report. Together, they build a stronger picture of the property’s condition and can help avoid disagreements later on. 

Check in evidence

At the beginning of the tenancy, it is good practice to create a comprehensive visual record of the property. This should include every room, as well as fixtures, fittings, appliances and any existing defects. 

A combination of photographs and video can be particularly effective. While video footage provides wider context and captures the overall condition of a room, photographs can be used to highlight specific details such as marks, scratches, chipped paintwork or worn flooring.

The more complete your check in evidence is, the easier it will be to compare the property’s condition at the end of the tenancy.

Focus on the areas that matter most 

Remember, not every part of a property attracts the same level of wear and tear. Some areas are more commonly disputed than others and should receive extra attention when recording evidence. 

These often include: 

  • Carpets and flooring 
  • Internal doors and handles 
  • Kitchen worktops and appliances 
  • Bathrooms and sanitaryware 
  • Walls and paintwork 
  • Gardens and outdoor spaces 

Detailed evidence of these areas can prove invaluable if questions arise later about cleaning, damage or maintenance. 

Quality makes the difference 

Even the most extensive collection of photographs can lose value if the images are unclear. Poor-quality evidence can make it difficult to accurately assess condition, identify damage or compare check in and check out records. 

When taking photographs or recording video footage, make sure: 

  • Rooms are well lit and free from shadows that could obscure important details 
  • Camera settings are set to the highest resolution available 
  • Images are sharp, clear and in focus 
  • Photographs are taken from multiple angles where necessary to provide context 
  • Excessive editing, filters or image enhancement are avoided 
  • Original digital files are retained and stored securely 

Please note: An adjudicator can only assess what they can clearly see. Grainy images, poor lighting or footage that moves too quickly may make it difficult to determine the true condition of an item or area. 

Provide context, not just photos 

Close up photographs are useful for showing marks, stains or damage, but they are most effective when accompanied by wider shots that show clearly the location. 

For example, a close up image of a scratch on a worktop tells part of the story. A wider photograph showing the entire kitchen helps identify exactly where the damage is located and provides important context. 

Where appropriate, including an item for scale, such as a ruler or measuring tape, can also help demonstrate the size and extent of any damage. 

Link visual evidence to your inventory 

Photographs and videos should not exist in isolation. 

The strongest evidence is usually clearly connected to the inventory report. Referencing image numbers within the inventory or embedding photographs alongside condition descriptions can make it much easier to understand what each image relates to. 

For example: 

Kitchen worktop – Item 3.2
Condition at check in: Good condition with no visible chips or scratches.
Supporting evidence: Photos 12-14.

This approach creates a clear trail between the written observations and the visual evidence. 

Authentication is key 

One of the most common weaknesses in photographic evidence is the inability to prove when it was taken. 

Where possible: 

  • Use date-stamped photographs 
  • Make sure inventory reports are dated and signed 
  • Store original image files 
  • Keep photographs embedded within check in and check out reports 
  • Retain metadata where available 

The easier it is to verify when evidence was created, the more weight it is likely to carry if a dispute arises.

Make videos easier to use 

Video can be extremely useful for documenting a property’s overall condition, but lengthy footage can be difficult to navigate. 

If you intend to rely on video evidence later, make sure it is organised and easy to reference. Move methodically through the property, identify each room clearly, and avoid recording footage too quickly. 

Where a specific issue is being highlighted, make sure the relevant section can be easily located and viewed without requiring someone to watch the entire recording. 

Only submit what’s relevant 

A comprehensive property record is worthwhile, but when presenting evidence in support of a claim, focus on the material that directly relates to the issue being disputed. 

The most persuasive evidence is often the evidence that clearly demonstrates: 

  • The condition at check out 
  • The specific change that occurred during the tenancy 
  • Why the change goes beyond fair wear and tear 

Providing concise, relevant evidence helps make sure the key points of a claim are clearly understood. 

Using our alternative dispute resolution 

After discussing the return of the deposit and any proposed deductions, you may not agree about how much should be returned. If this happens, the tenant can raise a dispute through our free alternative dispute resolution (ADR) service. 

Summary 

Photographs and videos can be powerful supporting evidence, but they are at their strongest when used alongside a detailed, accurate inventory. High-quality images, clear dates, thorough descriptions and consistent record keeping all help create a reliable picture of the property’s condition. 

In a deposit dispute, it is rarely a single photograph that makes the difference. It is the combination of inventories, photographs and videos working together to tell a clear, consistent and well documented story.